?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous | Next

why, oh why (on PTSD)

There was a thing on TV tonight, "World Trade Center: Anatomy of the Collapse". I shouldn't have watched it, really I shouldn't have, but I did. I couldn't help myself.

Mostly, it was interesting. Good discussions of the materials science and engineering that went into the unique construction of the buildings, and how that made the rental space so attractive, and the buildings inexpensive to put together. I guess it was that very efficiency that doomed them, because there was not a lot of redundancy built into the structures.

But of course they showed the goddamn planes crashing into them, over, and over and OVER again, and it brought everything back to me, the fear and vigilance and hatred, and I wound up crying quite a lot.

Worst of all were the interview segments with the senior structural engineer. He was very somber, and you could see it in his eyes, all that guilt and shame. I'm the world's only skyscraper designer whose creation failed.

"Do I feel a sense of responsibility for what happened? Guilt?" Then a barely perceptible nod, and he averted his eyes.

And later: "People talk about the 'twin towers' but they really are constructed quite differently. They aren't twins at all, and I don't think of them as twins." Then a sour expression of self-flagellation. "Damn, I keep getting my tense confused. WERE. They WEREN'T twin towers. ...Weren't."

Engineers have a propensity for being perfectionists, myself included, so I can identify only too well with his wanting to bear the weight of the disaster on his shoulders. I do the same thing myself whenever my network crashes. But all that death? All that carnage? I can't begin to imagine how he must feel.

"Come on, let yourself off the hook, honey!" Kate often tells me earnestly. I hope that gentleman has found a way. God bless you, sir.

Comments

( 2 comments — Comment )
starstraf
May. 22nd, 2002 07:55 am (UTC)
on the other hand
They repeatidly lowered the body count because more people were able to evacuate then they though. Before 9/11 no one ever thought that you had to protect a building from a flying fuel loaded jet liner. His design was strong enough to allow massive evacuation for a catastrophy that was not in the specs. That's damn good design.
Occupied by about 50,000 people Source and the final death toll was UNDER 3,000 people.

On Friday, February 26, 1993, a massive terrorist bomb was exploded in the Center's public parking garage, but the Towers survived.
jlindquist
May. 22nd, 2002 10:03 pm (UTC)
Re: on the other hand
Indeed. There's a strong pull to agonize over the people that couldn't be saved. As engineers, we know it's impossible to plan for every possibility, especially over the course of decades. We mourn the 3000 dead, but goddamn... we got 47,000 out. Let's raise a glass to the folks whose skill and care made that happen.l
( 2 comments — Comment )

Profile

14L
szasz
Charley

Latest Month

July 2013
S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031